Left column of masthead Center column masthead image Right column masthead

  • Home
  • New Inductees
  • Product Reviews / Evaluation Report Summaries (ERS)
  • Submit Product
  • Articles
  • More Links
  • Contact Us

The Toy Man® News & Views
Product Reviews / Evaluation Report Summaries (ERS)

Induction Certificate Number:   74020100701-433
Induction Date:   July 01, 2010
Certificate License Status:   Active
Product:   LiEBRARY - The Game Where the First Line Speaks Volumes
MSRP:   $29.99 USD
Company URL:  http://www.discoverybaygames.com

LiEBRARY - The Game Where the First Line Speaks Volumes

by:  Rev. James G.W. Fisher - Editor / Product & Service Evaluation Specialist
Evaluation Report Summary (ERS) Date:  07/01/2010

In LiEBRARY, players are given a book title and the plot summary and then asked to create the most believable first line of the book. The object of the game is to convince other players that your first line is the correct one...and this is just the start!

[ Please refer to A-2-Z Company Index for contact information.]

Participating in our eco-Recognition™ Project to encourage greenBusiness™

Product Type Release Year Primary Usage Target Age / Max. Weight Target Gender
Board Games 2009 Consumer/Education 12 and up Female/Male

Evaluation Report Summary (ERS)
Category Rating Scores

Category rating scores are based on scale from 1 to 5. Rating score must be 3 or higher to pass in each evaluation category.

Educational Value Design Quality Simplicity Visual Appeal FunFactor Safety
3.5 5 5 5 5 4.5

Critical Evaluation Information

These icons represent important attributes with which this product / service is associated, contributes to, or encourages development of. Select any of the unique icons below to learn more about the specific attribute it represents.

image of factory with ecological leaves symbol. Trade Industry Sales Types
Industry Memberships

Wholesale Retail Reseller Online 



Safety Guidelines Symbol ImageSafety / Quality Classifications
CE MarkedUL ApprovedJPMA Certified
(Not Applicable)(Not Applicable)(Not Applicable)
ASTM Complianteco-Friendlyeco-Conscious
(Not Applicable)

Independent Lab Tested  Independent Lab Name 

LeadSafe™ - Surface Coatings/PaintLeadSafe™ - Content / SubstratesPhthalatesSafe
BPASafeSoluble Heavy MetalsMechanical/Physical
Flammability - Solids/TextilesLabeling of Hazardous Art MaterialsiWatchDog™ Approved
(Complies with ICCS™ Certification Standards)

UPC Code / ISBN#Manufacturer SKUAge Grading
08127540133-4 1133Labeled/Appropriate

Manufactured InSafety Hazard/Warnings


    LieBRARY - Catalyst of Creativity and Challenge

LiEBRARY, (created by actresses Daryl Hannah and Hilary Shepard), isn't just another board game, rather it is a game which provides challenge which stimulates a player to call upon their creative thinking and skills, develop a strategy to win, and implement it.

In the game, players listen carefully as they are given the title and a summary of the book which has been selected by the LiEBRARIAN. Their task is then to create their own first line for the book and fool other players to vote for it to be the first line of the book. Book categories include Classics, Children's, Fiction/Nonfiction, Romance, and Mystery/Sci-Fi/Horror.

(If a player knows the actual first line of the book, they can write it as their line, but remember, the other players may not be familiar with that line and not vote for it.)

After all players have written their guesses, they are all turned in to the "LiEBRARIAN" face down, to be shuffled then read out loud to be voted upon. Once all of the lines have been read, the LiEBRARIAN reveals the real first line of the book and points are awarded. This is just the start...

    Of Course There Is More To The Game!

Of course there is more to the game silly! First of all, there is a two-minute timer that comes into play. Players have two-minutes to make their guesses and create their lines on their answer sheet.

  • One point is given to each player for each vote their line received
  • Two points are given to each player for guessing the correct line
  • Three points are given to the LiEBRARIAN if no one votes for the correct line

With this game you are looking at a plenty of fun, strong social interaction, and serious engagement in creativity! You can't just kick back and play LiEBRARY, the game draws you in and generates plenty of momentum to have a slap happy experience of fun and excitement!

In the images you see to the left and right above, you can see Daryl Hannah, one of the two creators of the game, holding the game and showing the components of the game inside the box in the second image.

A Powerful Collection Of Book Cards

One of the primary features which makes LiEBRARIAN so powerful is the fact of it having a card catalog of 350 Book Cards which are in 5 different categories;

  • Classics
  • Children's
  • Fiction/Non-Fiction
  • Romance
  • Mystery/Sci-Fi/Horror

The beauty of this game is how that with so many book cards and categories to choose from, repetitive game play is guaranteed along with an enlargement of a players knowledge base in books such as they never before imagined.

    Independent Evaluator Reports

Obtaining An Independent Perspective...

In this section we have called upon the assistance of top industry professionals to evaluate the product in this evaluation summary.

These scholars form their own opinions from extensive analysis and produce detailed, in-depth reports connected with their own personal study and evaluation of the products submitted for independent evaluation.

The information to follow is comprised of excerpts from the independent evaluator reports that have been paraphrased, posted verbatim, or a combination of both in order to encapsulate an accurate presentation of the primary details conveyed in each report. This approach provides a completely independent perspective in the evaluation each product.

PLEASE NOTE: At the request of our independent evaluators their names are not disclosed to protect their personal and professional privacy. Their labors are provided at no charge to assist us in providing a well-balanced and accurate product evaluation summary. Their title is provided to clarify for our readers the specific type of specialist from which each of the report excerpts have been authored. All opinions and or statements from the independent evaluator(s) featured here do not represent the opinion of The Toy Man® Product Guide, any member or division of GreyWolf Corp, or GreyWolf Corp itself.


MEDIA CONTENT: Personalized Music & Vocal Tracks
MEDIA CONTRIBUTION: Skill Development & Improvement
AGE GROUP: Designed for ages 12 and up

This Week's Independent Evaluators...

Behavior Change Communications Specialist, MEd.
Professor / Corporate Planning Analyst

"Liebrary unexpectedly captured my full attention in my initiatory examination of the game. The game box conduces the impression of an aged and well worn book which is impregnated into your conscious thought with such casual subtlety. The game is an empirical masterpiece with its uncanny ability to convey an instructive lesson with each card which is drawn. With each Liebrary card introduced, a clear elucidation of the book associated with it's title, creates an ambience of methodological conception and study."

"Liebrary summarizes and inter-blends famous collections of text into a well structured format which embeds equitable levels of literary knowledge and understanding into the players. Due to the practical research and study in the development of Liebrary, the full depth and breadth of this masterful game is as a fine wine, aged and requiring time to appreciate its full worth."

Professor of Psychology BA, MA, & Ph.D. - Educational Theory Specialist
Professor / Author / Educational Practices Advisor

"Liebrary assures the development of a narrative which holds an exceptionally strong influence in the players use of their short term recollection. This is a component in thought processing which is crucial for formation of predictions of what a player's opponents are likely to author in their own line for each card drawn from the deck."

"Liebrary serves as a strong 'virtual proponent' for significant development of active thought processing, and psycho-social interaction by way of a well planned creative agenda. The level of stimulation for each player to use comparative evaluation of game experience will be unique."

"As expected, the instructions and players role were clear and simple. The game box was light, and all of the playing pieces and die were easily accessed in the platform of the box."

"The game board was subtle in its color scheme and layout, especially with the board being a part of the actual game box and platform which were designed to look similar to a well worn book at a library while remaining visually appealing."

    Consumer Hands-On Evaluation

Nothing is more powerful than hands-on experience by a consumer with a product when it is under evaluation. Based upon that fact we put a number of products we currently are slated to evaluate at the mercy of consumers in a hands-on evaluation where anything goes. The information to follow will explore the responses from the participants in our spontaneous hands-on consumer evaluation of the products available for their review.

Image of a Kid Hip Personalized Childrens Music CD

LiEBRARY was a different kind of creature with this spontaneous consumer hands on-evaluation. Who would ever have imagined LiEBRARY being used for spontaneous hands-on consumer evaluation, but also with the participating staff and patients including myself as one of the patients!

When I first made the request to my nurse to inquire if any of the other patients or staff wanted to participate in this part of our evaluation, she inquired if I was kidding. Well, 3 hrs and 11 minutes later, the shift was changing and dinner had just arrived for the patients. While normally the spontaneous consumer hands on evaluation events are quite similar with a few special moments to remember, but this experience was like no other.



Changing The Atmosphere

It turns out that having LiEBRARY there for people to play changed the entire atmosphere for many of us. Instead of laying there debating with the other patients in the room what program we would watch next, the majority of us as well as two staff members were having a real riot of a time. Simple to play, not taking up a lot of space, and so easy put away quickly, LiEBRARY made a lot of people feel good, and forget about our pain, or for the staff, oops! work that needed to be done.

Amtrack Meets LiEBRARY

If that wasn't enough to give a good reading on LiEBRARY, a week later I went with my team of volunteers down to Union Station in Los Angeles, the Amtrack Station. We made the assumption that with so many people sitting there bored stiff while waiting for their train to arrive or board it, this was the perfect location for a spontaneous hands-on evaluation.

It seemed like just moments had turned into hours as we were playing LiEBRARY with a number of the travellers, just having fun. People would come and people would go, many of them willing to sit down and play LiEBRARY with one of our volunteers.  Even a conservative looking woman who was quiet as a mouse was eventually responding and giggling with each draw of the cards.

In Conclusion...

After our compiling the results from the feedback forms, LiEBRARY was a gem in the eyes of those who participated in playing, even a few who were just watching! They expressed how they wished they had opted in to play LiEBRARY instead of evaluating another game which was available to evaluate. LiEBRARY passed this evaluation segment smoothly and quite favorably.


    A Sampling Of Our Evaluation Category Ratings

A small sampling of the individual category titles & rating scores from the complete product review itself for this product are featured here. The categories which have been selected to be featured in this product evaluation summary for public view, specify some of the primary points of how and why that specific rating score was reached.

  • If a product is inducted, a product evaluation summary of the complete review is published for public view.
  • When a score has been assigned to a category rating, it has been through a thorough validation process to ensure accuracy and no inflection of bias.
  • If a product scores an overall category evaluation rating average of [2] Two Stars or lower from the complete review results, it fails the evaluation and is not inducted.
  • Information for products which do not pass our evaluation is confidential and is shared only with the company submitting the product.

The Featured Category Ratings Sample for this Product Evaluation Summary are listed below.

CREATIVE AGENDA: Rating Level - [3.5] an image of 3.5 gold  stars

Creative Agenda is a key element in the fundamental structure of a good board game. The creative agenda is what influences a player to develop a narrative of how they will play or even if they will continue to play. It inspires a person to create a narrative to win based upon desire, not skill comparison.

With LiEBRARY, a good creative agenda can be seen. Players are inspired to create their own unique narrative to win based upon desire, yet it still has a few hints of influence to wind based upon comparison of skills, strategies, or other factors. LiEBRARY passes well above average yet just not high enough to pull it to the next step up the ladder. LiEBRARY passes this evaluation category with a score of [3.5] stars for CREATIVE STRATEGY.

FUNFACTOR™: Rating Level - [5] an image of 5 gold  stars

FunFactor™ may be seen by some as a trivial factor in the evaluation of a game such as LiEBRARY, yet this evaluation category was selected out of the many others in the product evaluation to emphasize the importance and value of FunFactor™ in active Play. LiEBRARY has a most unique quality which will raise the level of FunFactor™ for any player by simply sitting down and playing one simple game. Once a person has played LiEBRARY just once, there's no going back. The immense level of fun and excitement which LiEBRARY gives birth to in a game demonstrates how "fun" is an absolute ingredient in the recipe for an exciting game where you can learn and have fun doing so!

During all phases of its evaluation, LiEBRARY, demonstrated that all those who joined in to play were in for an experience of a lifetime...and a fun one at that! There is nothing like the viral effect of a game with plenty of FunFactor™ and LiEBRARY has plenty of it. LiEBRARY steps up to complete this portion of our evaluation with a perfect score of [5] stars in this category for FunFactor™

Hybrid-Use™: Rating Level - [5] an image of 5 gold  stars

LiEBRARY found the evaluation category of Hybrid-Use™ to be a simple task to pass. Whether in a high school, at a trade show, with a family at home, or even a hospital, LiEBRARY was perfectly applicable for use in each environment and was even authorized for use at a public high school and a specialty hospital for life threatening health concerns. That is truly defining Hybrid-Use™!

LiEBRARY has pulled its boot straps and moves in comfortably with a perfect score of [5] Stars in this category for Hybrid-Use™.

INDIVIDUAL SKILL IMPROVEMENT: Rating Level - [5] an image of 5 gold  stars

The level of skill improvement with a player with LiEBRARY is well above average and then some! When you factor in the information and rating for each of the evaluation categories of this product evaluation summary, it is no challenge to see why the level of individual skill improvement for LiEBRARY was accomplished. Despite the stronger and more challenging evaluation standards recently adopted, LiEBRARY still managed to pass our evaluation in this category.

Skill improvement is vital for every individual with no exceptions. LiEBRARY provides a substantial contribution to a furtherance of each player's cognitive, physical, and social skills. LiEBRARY comes in at a fast pace with a perfect score of [5] Stars in this category for INDIVIDUAL SKILL IMPROVEMENT.

MARKETABILITY: Rating Level - [5] an image of 5 gold stars

MARKETABILITY is a home run for LiEBRARY. When you consider Daryl Hannah and Hilary Shepard being the creators of LiEBRARY, that there in itself speaks volumes. We look at that factor then move on to the other elements we need to consider in the marketability of a product.

LiEBRARY is a game that has all the right elements to really move. LiEBRARY has a very strong potential to pull ahead of the rest of the pack. Considering the incredible game design, FunFactor™, HybridUse™, individual skill improvement, and of course Daryl Hannah and Hilary Shepard in the mix, LiEBRARY pulls a screaming perfect score of [5] Stars in this category for MARKETABILITY.

VISUAL APPEAL: Rating Level - [4.5] an image of 4.5 gold  stars

VISUAL APPEAL posed an interesting challenge in our evaluation of LiEBRARY. The internal components of LiEBRARY raise even higher than well above average. Combined with the game box and platform you see an a visually appealing product which is above average, yet just not enough punch to get to the next digit.

With our new evaluation standards, visual appeal is a very strong factor in our evaluation process. The challenge here is that while we may fully understand the idea which the creators of LiEBRARY had in mind in regard to visual appeal, not everyone sees it through the same pair of glasses.

After several months of evaluation, analysis, and feedback, LiEBRARY finally made it in the gates with a passing score in this evaluation category of [4.5] stars for VISUAL APPEAL. The packaging for LiEBRARY is without question appealing yet just not enough to make us do any flips...(Well, maybe a flip or two.)

EVALUATION RESULTS - From evaluation for induction into "The Toy Man® News & Reviews"
    Overall Rating:   5
    Seal of Approval:  
    Recommends Award:  
    eco-Recognition™ Seal:  
    Award of Excellence:  
    eChoice™ Award:  
    S. T. E. M. Award:   
    Mom Approved Award:  
    Award of Recognition:™  


"The first and original Seal of Approval®...
designed for product recognition and validation."

Since 1971 The Toy Man® Seal of Approval has served as an emblem of professional recognition for a 
product or service having met the strict evaluation standards of The Toy Man® Product Guide. Since 1971, "The Toy Man® Seal of Approval" has served as an emblem and standard for professional recognition of a product or online service having met the globally recognized evaluation standards of The Toy Man® Product Guide.

This emblem was first established in 1971 by the International Parenting Institute™. It is modeled after the "Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval®", an emblem of recognition for products which meet the globally recognized high standards set forth by the Good Housekeeping Institute®.


"An emblem of the highest recognition...
for support of ecological concerns applied in full measure."

The Toy Man® eco-Recognition Seal™, by Rev. James
G.W. Fisher, (Chief editor and Product Evaluation Specialist of The Toy Man® Product Guide), and staff.  
These products have demonstrated that they possess the potential as well as high probability to be top sellers.
The Toy Man® eco-Recognition Seal™ embodies the highest recognition for products and services which provide a significant contribution to ecological concerns by one or more of the following;
- earthFriendly™ / Recycled / Recyclable materials are being used primarily or entirely in the manufacturing of the product.

- Product is or will soon be available exclusively or primarily online.


"These are globally recognized awards that are received by a limited few,
yet they provide the well earned recognition well beyond the average that is truly deserved!"

"The Toy Man® Award of Excellence" is awarded to inductees that have an overall Evaluation Category Rating Average, ECRA™, of [5] Stars. That is the highest level of rating available on a 1-5 scale evaluation model. The ECRA is based upon the overall average from all applicable evaluation categories"
PLEASE NOTE: There are a total of 357 evaluation categories with a minimum of 231 being applicable to any one product or online service in our evaluation process with 6 being featured in the Evaluation Report Summary, ERS.

The Toy Man® eChoice™ Award, by Rev. James
G.W. Fisher, (Chief editor and Product Evaluation Specialist of The Toy Man® Product Guide), and staff.  
These products have demonstrated that they possess the potential as well as high probability to be top sellers.
The Toy Man ®An image of the editorsChoice logo Award serves as an emblem of recognition for products & online services that contribute substantially to positive skill growth and/or productivity.

This distinguished award is exclusive as well as unique, with the editor's signature which represents a product being selected as an An image of the editorsChoice logo
PLEASE NOTE: The eChoice™ Award images which were used from 1971-1984, 1984-2007 and 2007-April 2010 have been retrired. Although the versions of the eChoice™ Award have been retired, they still remain valid.

Untitled Document